Trade In or Sell Privately? What You Have To Know About Retail, Wholesale, and Listing Prices For Cars

Motori Media Logo

Trade In or Sell Privately? What You Have To Know About Retail, Wholesale, and Listing Prices For Cars

“How do I get the most out of my car’s value?” This question might come to mind when you consider selling or trading in your car and it can be difficult to decide which strategy is best. 

You don’t want to leave money on the table by underselling your car, but you also don’t want to lose out on potential customers by pricing it too high. While trading in your car is often the quickest and easiest option, there are benefits to selling your car privately as well. 

Understanding the different pricing options will be an advantage in making the right decision for anyone looking to get the most out of their vehicle. Here, we’ll explore winning options and tips for you when you’re looking to trade or sell your car.

When choosing between trading or selling a car privately, it’s important to consider how they differ when it comes to costs. Because, while it might not seem like it, some of the prices offered to you could include hidden expenses.

selling car signs

Financing Your Car and the Costs of Selling or Trading In

When it comes to financing your car, taxes are always included in the loan amount and are considered sunk costs. Depending on the situation, selling the car privately may be the best option, but the taxes must be paid again by the buyer.

Alternatively, dealerships may be able to help you avoid taxes on your car by taking the vehicle as a trade-in. However, they will likely offer less than the market value and make money off of the trade in car dealership transactions.

It’s important to evaluate all your financing options to determine the best course of action. So, let’s take a look at the multiple price points for a car.

1. Listing Value 

A car’s listing value or price is its estimated market value based on factors such as its make, model, age, and condition. It’s usually calculated using industry-standard pricing guides and takes into account the current market value of similar cars. A listing value is usually determined by a car appraisal expert or a car-buying website. 

The car listing value is used to determine the fair market value of a car, which can be used as a guide for setting the car’s price when it is listed for sale.

On the other hand, if negotiation is your strongest suit, you might want to consider your car’s retail value.

2. Retail Value 

The retail value of a car is the amount of money it’s worth when sold to an individual consumer by a dealer. This is the optimum price for which the dealer wishes to sell it. The car’s retail value can vary significantly based on its condition, features, year, and demand.

This is great news for people who are good at negotiating because it means they can always offer great deals, which increases their chances of getting a good price for their car.

If that’s too much of a hassle for you, there’s a more convenient option. By opting for a vehicle wholesale value, you’ll get plenty of benefits!

3. Wholesale Price  

The main benefit of opting for a wholesale deal when selling your car is that you can save a lot of money. You can often get a better price for your car than if you were to sell it on the open market, as dealers typically offer better deals than individual buyers.

Opting for a wholesale deal can give you a sense of security, knowing that your car is being handled by a professional. When you go with a professional dealer like Motori, we offer value-added services for your cars, like car detailing and repairs

A wholesale deal allows you to sell your car directly to a dealership or other third-party buyer instead of having to go through the hassle of putting it up for sale yourself. This can save you time and money, as you don’t have to deal with advertising and haggling over the price.

Now that you know the different pricing points when selling a car and how they work, you must also weigh the pros and cons of trading or selling a car. Tax advantages and receiving higher payouts of selling your car against the drawbacks and effort required to sell it yourself is a tricky process when making a decision.

The Pros and Cons of Trading In or Selling Privately


  • Trade In – The biggest favour of trading in is convenience and tax advantage. Trading your car is usually the quickest and easiest way to sell it, as all you have to do is bring it to a dealership and they’ll take care of the rest. A trade in car price will be your biggest win. The dealership will typically offer you a trade-in value for your car, which can be used towards the purchase of a new one. The dealership will handle all of the paperwork and the trade-in process, and you’ll have cash in hand.


  • Sell Privately – When you sell your car privately, you’ll likely get more money for it than if you traded it in depending on your strategy. There’s no middleman in a private sale, so you get to keep more of the money you make from the sale. This method also gives you more control over the sale process. You can decide when and where to list your car, and you can negotiate the price directly with the buyer. This gives you the chance to get a better deal, as long as you’re a good negotiator.


  • Trade in – Unfortunately, trade in car dealerships also has drawbacks. The biggest downside is that you’ll likely get less money for your car when you trade it in than you would if you sold it privately. Dealerships need to make a profit on the car for the service they provide. It’s also worth noting that, depending on the dealership you go to, you may be able to negotiate a better price. However, this can be difficult, especially if you’re not one to negotiate.


  • Sell privately – One of the biggest disadvantages of selling a car privately are the days and weeks you have to sink into selling your car. You’ll need to take the time to advertise, show the car to buyers, and negotiate a price. This can be time-consuming and stressful. Also, keep in mind that there is always the possibility that you won’t find a buyer or that the buyer will back out of the deal. This is especially true if you’re selling an older car. 


Overall, trading in or selling privately both have their advantages and disadvantages. It’s important to consider your individual situation and decide which option is best for you. 


Finally, the question boils down to this: what is the best strategy to sell a car?

What is the Best Strategy to Get the Most Out of Your Car?

The advancement of technology has revolutionized the automotive industry. It has streamlined the process of buying, selling, and maintaining cars, making it easier and more efficient for car sellers. With the use of dealer apps and tools, dealerships are able to offer more to customers while still keeping their margins low.

This has allowed customers to get the best deals on their cars and has ultimately improved the overall experience for car sellers. The digitization of the system has made it possible to have a consistent stream of buyers and has led to the growth of online car dealerships.

If you choose to go with a professional car dealer, you’ll be assured that you’ll get a good deal out of your car without a hassle. Motori Auto Sales provides a free service to valuate your car; we’re professionals that take a smaller cut of the car’s valuation for the trade in car price.

Trading in your car with Motori is also an easy way to get rid of a car with minimal hassle. Damages from your car will be covered by wholesale, so you don’t have to worry about them when you come with us.

The best option for you will depend on your specific situation. If you’re looking for a quick and easy way to part with your car, trading it in may be the best option. On the other hand, if you’re looking to get the most money for your car, selling it privately may be the best way to go. Whichever route you choose, make sure to do your research and understand each option before making a decision.

Motori Track Event // Aug 4 2024 DDT

Motori Track Event // Aug 4 2024 DDT

Thank you all for coming to our 2022 Shannonville Lapping event. Hope you all the…

Tesla Changing Auto Market Trends and Considerations

Tesla Changing Auto Market Trends and Considerations

The global auto industry is at crossroads. As the industry evolves, it’s becoming clear that…

Trade In or Sell Privately? What You Have To Know About Retail, Wholesale, and Listing Prices For Cars

“How do I get the most out of my car’s value?” This question might come…

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *